Screwdriver sets: the source’s Craftsman leader

Original test: Mar 2025Catalog checked: Nov 5, 2026Testing by Project Farm

Bench places Craftsman first at an average finish of 3.3 and Mayhew second at 3.7 in the March 2025 screwdriver-set comparison. The matched sets are Craftsman 25006 and Mayhew 66300.

Source: Project Farm’s Bench catalog Watch the original Project Farm test

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How links work

Source first place

Craftsman Extreme Grip 25006

6-piece diamond-tip screwdriver set

The source ranks this tested model first in this comparison. See the linked result for the measurements and test context.

Check price at Amazon

Affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

See source & result

Verified Results

2 published tested models

2 matched source configurations; not the full original lineup.

Source ranks are shown only where supported. “Not ranked” means no overall ordering is published here.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How links work

Swipe horizontally to see all results and retailer links.

Products and verified results for Screwdriver sets: the source’s Craftsman leader
		Source-supported result	Retailer choices
1	Craftsman Extreme Grip 250066-piece diamond-tip screwdriver setSource first place	Average finish: 3.3 average finishing positionSource · The verdict: Craftsman, first, average finish 3.3 Strengths & limitations Source-supported strengths Explicit selected source result; package identity checked separately.Source · The verdict: Craftsman, first, average finish 3.3 Limitations One exact source-linked set. No comparison of current prices or results for newer similarly named sets.Source · The verdict: Craftsman, first, average finish 3.3	Check price at Amazon We may earn a commission.
2	Mayhew 66300 Cats Paw6-piece Cats Paw screwdriver set	Average finish: 3.7 average finishing positionSource · The verdict: Mayhew, second, average finish 3.7 Strengths & limitations Source-supported strengths Explicit supported source position/average with separately matched purchase configuration.Source · The verdict: Mayhew, second, average finish 3.7 Limitations One exact six-piece set. No different kit/series substitution or current-price comparison.Source · The verdict: Mayhew, second, average finish 3.7	Check price at Amazon We may earn a commission.

Test Method & Context

Manual reading of the selected official Bench verdict and its individually chosen product reference. Product configuration was checked against merchant identity fields and, where available, official model information. PF Shop did not perform the experiment.

Limitations to Keep in Mind

One exact source-linked set. No comparison of current prices or results for newer similarly named sets.

Source-supported result

Craftsman Extreme Grip 25006: Why This Result Matters

The source ranks this tested model first in this comparison. See the linked result for the measurements and test context.

This result applies to the model and configuration in the original test.

See product details

Before You Buy

Check included driver profiles and sizes for the work. A source result for this set should not be transferred to every Craftsman screwdriver or a similarly named newer set.

Go Straight to the Source

PF Shop summarizes results attributed to Project Farm in Bench. Read the catalog entry for the source verdict and lineup, and the video for the testing context.

Read the Bench entry Watch on YouTube

Related Tests

All tests